Addressing the Urgent Need for Criminal Justice Reform: NPA Head Advocates Overhaul of Outdated Legislation

In a recent statement, Advocate Shamila Batohi, the head of South Africa's National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), highlighted the pressing need for comprehensive reform within the country's criminal justice system. Batohi's remarks came during the Justice Department’s conference on the integration of the criminal justice system, where she underscored the inadequacies of the current legal framework, particularly the outdated Criminal Procedure Act of 1977 (CPA).

It was emphasised that the existing criminal justice system is dysfunctional and fails to serve the interests of the people. Batohi pointed out that the CPA, which serves as the primary legislation governing criminal courts, is largely out of touch with the realities of contemporary crime in South Africa. As discussions unfolded at the conference, it became evident that a complete overhaul of the CPA is long overdue.

One of the key areas of concern raised during the conference was Section 35 of the Criminal Procedure Act, which addresses the right to a fair and speedy trial. Batohi emphasised the prolonged delays in court cases, highlighting that while a speedy trial is a fundamental right, it remains elusive within a system fraught with inefficiencies. She stressed the urgency of addressing these challenges to ensure that the criminal justice system upholds the lofty ideals enshrined in the Constitution.

Speaking on behalf of prosecutors, Batohi expressed hope that revamping the CPA would enable the legal framework to better address the complexities of contemporary crime and enhance the efficacy of law enforcement efforts. Recognising the need for substantial reforms, she acknowledged that merely adjusting the existing legislation would not suffice. Instead, a comprehensive overhaul is necessary to align the legal framework with the evolving nature of crime in South Africa.

The call for reform echoes broader concerns within the legal community and civil society regarding the shortcomings of the criminal justice system. It is imperative for stakeholders to collaborate closely in the process of legislative reform, ensuring that the revised framework is robust, equitable, and responsive to the needs of all citizens.

As discussions continue, it is essential to prioritise transparency, accountability, and inclusivity in the reform process. Meaningful engagement with stakeholders, including legal experts, law enforcement agencies, and civil society organisations, will be crucial in shaping a criminal justice system that commands public trust and delivers justice effectively.


Advocate Shamila Batohi's call to modernise outdated laws highlights the urgent need to rectify systemic deficiencies within South Africa's criminal justice system. Through committed efforts to reform, stakeholders have the opportunity to establish a legal framework that is fair, equitable, and genuinely beneficial to all citizens

Original Article Credit:
 "Criminal Procedure Act outdated and out of touch with today's crime in SA – Batohi"

Intellectual property disclaimer:
The contents of any article published by CTC Stander & Associates should not be construed as professional legal advice.